Thanksgiving pumpkin pie recipe

October 23, 2019

With 2.9 million posts on Instagram using the hashtag #pumpkinpatch, pumpkins are more popular than ever. Is it even Autumn/Fall if your feed doesn’t have someone holding a pumpkin with a pun in the caption? If it doesn’t, just go follow me, I’m one of those people! We can’t just go running through pumpkin patches without taking one or two home though and sure we can carve them, it’s one of my favourite things to do this time of year, but we could MAKE PIE!

I’ve never been to America during fall/autumn, I’ve always wanted to though as it’s no secret that they take the holidays very seriously from pumpkin drinks to pumpkin decorations. Alas, I’m just going to have to bring that spirit into my home instead, and you can too with this classic American dessert.


Pumpkin pie is THE dessert for the holidays across North America and is consumed on both the Canadian and American Thanksgivings. The recipe below actually comes from an American friend of the family, and has been in my Mum’s recipe book for decades, but it has been adapted to make the pumpkin filling and pastry from scratch as the original recipe asks for a pre-made pastry and tinned pumpkin which is then seasoned, so you get extra bragging rights for using this recipe! There’s even a couple of quick recipes at the end on what to do with the seeds, so nothing goes to waste!

This recipe will make two pies as even a small pumpkin like the one I used will make enough filling for two. This way you can eat one and freeze the other for Friendsgiving or Thanksgiving if you’re making these for Hallowe’en.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 1

PFH Fun Fact: Pumpkins are a fruit, I googled it.




142g Butter

284g plain flour

56g caster sugar

2-4 tbsp water

Pumpkin filling

The flesh of one medium pumpkin

1/4 cup golden caster sugar

1/4 cup white caster sugar

1 1/2 cups of undiluted evaporated milk

1/2 tsp salt

1 tsp cinnamon

1/2 tsp ginger

1/4 tsp of nutmeg

1/4 tsp allspice

A pinch of ground cloves

2 eggs

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 1 1



Wooden spoon

2 mixing bowls

Flour dredger


Sharp knife

Chopping board


Rolling pin

Pastry mat (or a clean and flat surface)

2 20cm (8”) round tins

Blind bake beads

Measuring cups


Tsp measurement

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 2



1. Preheat the oven to 180°C (356°F).

2. Measure out ingredients.

3. Add the butter to the flour and rub with your fingertips to create a crumble like texture.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 3

4. Stir in the sugar.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 4

5. Add 1 tbsp of water and stir through, keep adding water in small amounts and stir through until the mixture becomes a dough. Do not add all of the water at one time because you don’t want a wet dough.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 5

6. When you are able to, use your hands to roll your dough into a ball.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 6

7. Using the flour dredger, scatter some flour over a flat surface (either a table, kitchen counter or a pastry mat) and rolling pin, then place dough upon the surface.

8. Cut the ball of pastry in half and round off each half.

9. Roll out one half of the pastry, turning and flipping it whilst re-flouring the surface and rolling pin as you go until the pastry will fit one of the tins at a thickness of 5mm (1/4”).

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 7

10. Lightly grease the tins with butter and dust with flour to prevent the pastry from sticking.

11. Place the pastry over the round tin and gently press it in.

12. Lift up the tin and using a knife, trim the excess pastry from the edges.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 8

13. Repeat steps 7 – 11 with the other half of the dough.

14. Line the pastry with a scrap of parchment paper and, if you have them, evenly place the blind baking beads into the two round tins to weigh down the pastry as it bakes. If you don’t have them then use the excess pastry that you trimmed off to create small balls to weigh down the pastry.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 9

15. Place them into the oven, putting your best one on the middle shelf and the other on the lower.

16. Bake at 180°C (356°F) for 15mins then turn the heat down to 150°C (300°F) for a further 10mins.

17. Remove the beads and check if the pastry has dried out beneath them. If it has, remove the tins from the oven and let them sit. If they aren’t dry after the beads have been removed, place the tins back into the oven (without the beads) for a further 2mins or until they have dried.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 10

18. You can now move onto the filling.

Pumpkin filling 

1. Turn the oven down to a lower heat whilst you prepare the pumpkin. Depending on how soft your pumpkin is, peeling and preparing it could be time-consuming so you don’t want to lose the heat from the oven, but you also don’t want to waste energy.

2. Measure out the ingredients.

3. Cut the pumpkin into more manageable chunks.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 11

4. Remove the seeds and general mush (put aside for later, see below).

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 1 2

5. Peel the skin off, making sure to remove all of the tough exterior.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 2 1

6. Chop the pumpkin into chunks.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 3 1

7. Add the chunks into a saucepan with 1 cup of water.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 4 1

8. Place the saucepan onto a medium heat until the pumpkin is soft and mushy, regularly stirring it to make sure it isn’t sticking to the bottom. You want to cook it like you’re making mashed potato.

9. When the pumpkin is really mushy, stir it with a wooden spoon to make a smooth purée.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 5 1

10. Add the pumpkin to a mixing bowl.

11. Stir in the golden caster sugar, white caster sugar, salt, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, ground cloves and eggs until it’s a smooth, creamy consistency.

12. Pour into the pie casings (or use a ladle if you want to be more precise), filling them to about 1/2cm from the top of the crust.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 12

13. Place the pies in the oven for 15mins at 180°C (356°F) then reduce the heat to 150°C (300°F) and cook for a further 25mins

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 1 3

14. Turn the oven off (or down if you want to roast the seeds, see below) and leave the pies on top to cool down

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 2 2

15. Slice the pie to serve it. You can serve it with single cream, whipped cream, squirty cream or ice cream.

PFHPostcardsfromHawaiiPumpkinPieRecipeFoodandDrinkThanksgivingBakingHalloweenUSAAmerica 3 2

Toasted pumpkin seeds

Even if you’re not making pumpkin pie, flavouring and toasting your seeds after carving pumpkins will prevent them going to waste. They’re a great snack with a glass of vino or an after-school treat – plus a lesson to show kids not to let anything go to waste.


  1. Remove the pumpkin goop from the seeds and lightly dry them with a cloth

  2. Place them as evenly as possible onto a tray

  3. Drizzle them with oil

  4. Sprinkle cinnamon and sugar over them

  5. Toast in the oven at 180°C (356°F) for 3-4 mins (or until you hear them popping)

  6. Allow them to cool for 5mins

  7. Put them into a smaller pot (a ramekin should do it) and stir through an extra teaspoon (or two) of sugar

  8. Serve!


  1. Remove the pumpkin goop from the seeds and lightly dry them with a cloth

  2. Place them as evenly as possible onto a tray

  3. Drizzle them with oil

  4. Sprinkle salt, pepper, garlic or paprika (anything of your choice) over them

  5. Toast in the oven at 180°C (356°F) for 3-4 mins (or until you hear them popping)

  6. Allow them to cool for 5mins

  7. Put them into a smaller pot (a ramekin should do it) and serve!


Aloha, Gabriella

Pin this post

Leave a Reply

Get Sharing

Recent posts

Snow-capped mountains covered in evergreen trees in British Columbia in Canada for blog post titled 10 ways to cope with and work through homesickness.
Whether you’re at university or the other side of the world here’s 10 ways to cope with and work through homesickness.
Postcards from Hawaii Travel Lifestyle Blog How to make crochet pumpkins - free crochet pattern and tutorial halloween autumn fall Thanksgiving Friendsgiving crochet pattern
Free crochet pattern & tutorial for how to make crochet pumpkins. Learn how to make little plush pumpkins or big pumpkin cushions.
From clam juice cocktails to Indigenous bread, here’s 10 Canadian foods to try when you visit Canada.
postcards from hawaii travel lifestyle blog 6 fun things to do in Osoyoos, British Columbia Canada Travel Guide vacation wine tasting
6 fun things to do in Osoyoos on vacation that isn’t just wine tasting. Plan your trip to Osoyoos, Canada with this mini Osoyoos travel guide.
Postcards from Hawaii Travel Lifestyle Blog Pimm's cake recipe with zesty Pimm's drizzled glaze loaf cake recipe summer Wimbledon Pimm's Fruit Cup
Recipe for making a Pimm’s loaf cake with a zesty, sweet Pimm’s drizzled glaze. Perfect for Wimbledon, picnics, lunches, BBQs & summer parties.
Best second-hand, vintage and thrift stores in Vancouver, Postcards from Hawaii, Travel Lifestyle Blog, Gabriella Wisdom, Burcus, Salvation Army, Value Village, Canada
A list of the best second-hand, vintage and thrift stores in Vancouver so you can look cool & save money and furnish your home on a low budget.

Save for later

Create an account so you can save your favourite blog posts


More Like This

How to make crochet pumpkins – free crochet pattern and tutorial

August 31, 2023

10 Canadian foods to try when you visit Canada

August 10, 2023

6 fun things to do in Osoyoos, British Columbia

July 20, 2023

Pimm’s cake recipe with zesty Pimm’s drizzled glaze

July 6, 2023

Top 10 free museums and galleries to visit in London

June 1, 2023

Things to do in Newtown & Enmore, Sydney Australia

May 11, 2023

Why you should stay at Fairmont Chateau Lake Louise during winter

March 16, 2023

Recipe for heart-shaped pop-tarts for Valentine’s Day

February 2, 2023

How to make vegetable broth (stock or bouillon) with vegetable scraps

January 19, 2023

How to spend a day in Bavarian Village, Leavenworth: Christmastown USA

December 15, 2022